A tour group listening on a dark Salem street

Dr. Vitka's Files

Sometimes the Kids Are Telling the Truth

A child on the walk described something she had never been told about. What happened next, and why children make better witnesses than adults.

Children are the best witnesses on a ghost tour, and the reason has nothing to do with sensitivity. It has to do with what they have not been told.

The night it happened

A family of four joined the walk on a cool Tuesday in September. Their daughter was about nine, quiet, holding her mother's hand at the back of the group. We stopped at the Lyceum on Church Street, and I told the story of the woman in the upstairs window — a report that predates the restaurant and has survived a renovation.

Before I finished, the girl said, "She's not in the window, she's in the hall." Then she described a narrow corridor, a door at the end, and a smell she did not like.

The restaurant's upper floor does have a corridor and a door at the end of it. It is not visible from the street, and it is not part of the story I tell.

Why I did not make a fuss

The temptation in that moment is to turn it into a show. I did not, for two reasons. First, a child who is suddenly the centre of attention in a group of strangers will often elaborate — not because she is lying, but because she is being rewarded. Second, her parents were now alarmed, and my job was to keep the evening calm.

I asked her one question: had she been in the building before? She had not. I thanked her, moved the group on, and mentioned it to her mother at the end of the night.

What makes a child's account useful

Children describe what they see rather than what it means. An adult says "I felt a presence." A child says "there was a man in the doorway and he was wearing a brown coat." The second is testable; the first is not.

Children are also less likely to have read the local ghost literature, which means they cannot accidentally reproduce it. When a nine-year-old describes a detail that appears in a book she has never opened, that is worth noting.

What it does not prove

It does not prove a ghost. Children overhear things, see reflections, and build pictures from fragments. The corridor could have been glimpsed through a window from a different angle. The smell could have been the kitchen.

What it does is add a data point to a file that already has several. That is how investigation works — slowly, with doubt, and without a camera crew.

If your child says something on the tour

Tell me. Do not prompt them, do not correct them, and do not ask leading questions in front of the group. Write down what they said as soon as you can. Children's accounts are fragile and valuable, and the worst thing you can do is help.

The walk runs nightly from the Revere Bell at the Salem Visitor Center. It is all-ages, and the children often notice more than the adults.

Dr. Vitka

Dr. Vitka is a Salem historian, licensed city guide and professional paranormal investigator. He leads the Spellbound Tour nightly and hosts the Spellbound podcast.

Keep reading

Reserve your place

Walk these stories in person.

The Spellbound Tour runs nightly from the Revere Bell at the Salem Visitor Center. From $28, all ages, rain or shine.

Ask a Question

Nightly tours · All ages · Rain or shine · (978) 740-1876